I suppose it’s possible, but with the scenario you described, I wouldn’t say that’s likely to be what happened. Your brain is very, very good at pattern recognition, and does it subconsciously. There’s a reason you’re told to trust your gut feeling about strangers, and err on the side of caution. I’d say something about that guy set off that pattern recognition. Maybe falsely, maybe not. The guy could’ve been a normal guy entirely and you could’ve just had a false alarm, or maybe he was dangerous in some way, and that pattern recognition held up the closest equivalent, which is the person you remember.
The only time I’d say that it’s likely that you sensed their soul is if you had a friend, and you had a feeling that their kintype was X, didn’t mention it, and they later turned out to be X without you telling them (and thus, without being influenced by what you thought). It’s possible. It doesn’t happen often, but it’s possible. It happened to me with my qpp – I saw them when we first met, and every instinct was going off and saying “hey. hey you see that person? they’re Important. they are Important With A Capital I. that is a Main Character right there.” Well, we’ve been in a happy relationship for almost a year (as well as being canonmates!), so I did pick up on that.
But it’s not a common occurrence, and is not the most likely explanation for what you saw. Now, if you saw the guy again, and got to know him, and turned out to be right, then it’s a lot more likely you sensed that connection. But it’s more likely to be simple pattern recognition / gut feeling that something was wrong, and that’s fine. Humans are good at that, and you picked up on your gut feeling and recognized that this was a Problem Situation. That’s a handy and well-developed survival trait, and yes, if you’re in another Problem Situation, that may just save your life.
I’d suggest being aware of it when it happens in the future anyhow, because you never really know. Either way, whether it’s spiritual or plain ol’ danger sense, it’s good to recognize that and be aware of it when it’s telling you that you need to get out of there. So looks like you’re fine to me.
~Mod Lu